沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago @Edit 9 months ago


有三成的英國民眾不知道社會性別跨女是生理男性,如果簡稱跨女,更有約四成的民眾不明白所指對象的生理性別為何
A third of Britons don’t know that transgender women...
Survation carried out separate polls for each term, of 1,008 and 1,026 UK adults, between June 15 and 19, and June 23 and 26.

覺得這篇報導很適合拿來檢視政府那些「術語問卷調查」,例如柚子旅人提出過的世新跨性別政策問卷調查只為特定團體喉舌的世新性別變更法制化研究案 | No Self ID Taiwan 反對自我宣稱性別
latest #24
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
中文沒有區分社會性別跟生理性別的習慣,通常大家講性別就是指生理性別,在用語上需要更多介紹,但往往政府或NGO都不會在名詞上琢磨,甚至連已術跟未術都不願意區分
明明這些把持權力的人都知道「已術」跟「未術」對於台灣來說,是一個很重要的意見分水嶺,但他們為了自己的方便,從前不會、以後也不會在問卷調查裡面揭露訊息
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
https://images.plurk.com/7waF7yLjjQaZP9CwFa7yr0.jpg
喔對還有一些跨運信徒是長這樣
「跨女是生理女因為他們是女」
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
喔對,底下留言有人提到trans umbrella(跨運大傘),真的很感謝第一起免術換證的時候Y旅人做了跨運大傘的中文宣傳圖
立即下載
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
https://images.plurk.com/57EfDiWQzymW3AWGi8kerX.png
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
Broma on TwitterI remember the lady in the Wii Spa case saying to the receptionist sounding very confused "But he's not trans, he has a penis..."

這也是一個點,台灣社會也通用,當大家認為跨性別=變性人=已手術的時候,當然「包容度」就會比較高,但會影響政策的問卷都很巧妙的避開了「有沒有手術」這點
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
The Lies They Tell on TwitterAnd I also think that a lot of people believe that a sex change operation is like a transplant, rather than cosmetic.

「變性手術」這點也很妙,目前台灣還好是因為釋函還在那,所以大家對於變性手術的印象還是摘除腺體,但當免術開始,那麼「變性手術」是不是就跟現在一堆跨女宣稱的一樣了?
我隆乳!我整形!我超級pass!
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
Gordon Raw on Twitter
Which is why the phrase ‘trans identified male’ is supposedly offensive. It’s because it’s accurate and easily understood, which is the last thing that TRAs want.

精闢 這就是為什麼他們認為強調「男跨」是冒犯的
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
「未術男跨」在他們眼裡冒犯到爆炸,但如果政府想要做出實質意義上的調查,這卻是必要的資訊揭露 然後又回到政府沒有精力也不想審核專家們的意見問題
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
MBM said several bodies, such as the BBC, regularly used the terms without further explanation, for example, in stories about transgender participation in sport or the debate over self-ID.
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
In many cases, the terms were adopted as a result of lobbying from trans rights activists, who often claim it is discriminatory and offensive to refer to a transgender person’s biological sex.
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
突然想到之前公投也被罵雙重否定讓很多人看不懂在幹嘛
因為說得太清楚會被發現啊
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
xxx83221: 遇到說太清楚的人大喊歧視就可以解決這個問題了
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
再複習一下,被ㄅㄌㄇ威脅提告的柚子旅人有節錄世新問卷問題與政府缺失只為特定團體喉舌的世新性別變更法制化研究案 | No Self ID Taiwan 反對自我宣稱性別
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
ToothbrushMaestra on TwitterOur group WRNDerbyshire have had this when on the streets talking to people. A man thought transwoman in women's sports was women taking testosterone.
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
開了「讓女人表達想法是危害跨性別生存」戰場的人:
https://images.plurk.com/2ZrRc6uqb6pet7u0yCotd5.jpg
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
⬆️這個人的場外戰場Helen Staniland on TwitterBrennan on Twitter
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
個人認為政府也需要揭露所謂「精神科醫生鑑定」很大一部分也是基於刻板印象
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
WeAreFairCop on Twitter
Female is an adjective, not a noun, according to @ StaffsPolice. And not all women are female.
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
也是滿多人在罵那些分不清楚的人是不是蠢蛋的Disclose.tv on Twitter這推的引推跟留言就比較多
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
Wings Over Scotland on TwitterWe did some similar polling a few months ago, but then weren't able to release the results because TRAs had mired the polling company in so many complaints.
有人說做了類似的調查,但因為被支持者投訴所以停擺
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
這個跟跨運倡議「性別是隱私」比較有關The Critic on Twitter
大概是在講英國可以更改出生性別,以及視性別為隱私之後發生了什麼執行上的衝突Secrets and lies | Maya Forstater | The Critic Magaz...
沙發馬鈴薯
9 months ago
原推說是不是那群領養老津貼的人分不清楚B52Ed on Twitter「就是我們這群領養老津貼過活的人才有時間去搞清楚那些詞啦」
back to top